Turnover among recruiters at US staffing firms reached an estimated 46.3% in 2024. Account executives weren't far behind at 44.2%. Both figures are ClearlyRated estimates based on more than 5,000 survey responses, shared by the American Staffing Association (ASA).
In this business, every one of those exits carries risk. A recruiter who leaves knows your hiring managers. They know your candidates too. Few industries give one employee both sides of the deal.
That's what makes client poaching in recruitment and staffing agencies so damaging. A former recruiter can call your client with a shortlist built from your own candidate database.
So what can a departing recruiter actually take? And what can you do to limit it?
What Can a Departing Recruiter Take?
A departing recruiter can leave with hiring manager contacts, candidate resumes, open job orders and your fee terms. Whether they're allowed to use any of it depends on what they signed, your state's law and how well you protected the data. Here's what is usually within reach.
- Hiring manager contacts. Not the HR inbox on a company website. These are the direct lines of the people who approve job orders and agree to fees.
- Your candidate database. Current resumes, salary expectations, notice periods and interview notes. For many agencies, that's years of work.
- Open job orders, including which roles are urgent and which clients are unhappy with their current shortlist
- Fee agreements and bill rates. A recruiter who knows your percentage or markup knows what to undercut.
- Contractors on assignment. In temporary staffing, a recruiter with close ties to placed workers can try to move them to a rival's payroll.
Then there's LinkedIn. Recruiters build their networks on personal profiles. Every hiring manager and candidate they connect with stays in that network after they leave.
How Does Client and Candidate Data Leave the Agency?
Usually through everyday tools, a little at a time. A recruiter stealing clients rarely needs to do anything that looks unusual.
- ATS exports. One search saved as a spreadsheet can hold hundreds of candidates with their contact details.
- Resumes and client emails forwarded to a personal inbox
- Candidate records copied into personal notes or cloud storage such as Google Drive or Dropbox
- Personal phones. Every call or text from a recruiter's own cell leaves that number in their contacts.
- Connected tools. Browser extensions, sourcing tools and AI assistants linked to your ATS can read records in bulk, so check what each one has access to.
We cover these methods in more detail in our post on how employees steal clients.
Why Are Staffing Agencies So Exposed?
Three things come together.
People move often. With turnover at the levels above, most agencies will see recruiters leave every year. Some join a competitor. Others open their own desk.
The work also depends on open access. Recruiters need to search the full candidate pool in the applicant tracking system (ATS) to fill roles quickly. Lock the database down too hard and placements slow.
Finally, much of the information looks public. That weakens your legal position if you haven't protected it. In Sasqua Group v. Courtney, an executive search firm serving the financial services industry tried to stop a former recruiter from using its client database. A federal magistrate judge in the Eastern District of New York turned down the trade secret claim in 2010.
Two things counted against the firm. Much of the information could be pieced together from sources like LinkedIn and Google. The firm also hadn't taken basic steps to protect it. The recruiter had never been asked to sign a confidentiality or non-solicitation agreement. Computers weren't password protected and every employee had free access to the database (ERE, Fisher Phillips).
What Do Recent Court Cases Show?
Columbia Technology v. EJR Search Partners (2026)
Columbia Technology is an IT recruiting and staffing company that places candidates with financial services clients. It claimed one of its own recruiters had passed candidate details from its database to a rival firm, EJR Search Partners. EJR then placed those candidates and kept the fees.
On June 30, 2026, a New York appeals court upheld the ruling against EJR. Two placements were at the center of the case. In the first, EJR earned a $45,787 commission. Its principals argued they already knew the candidate. The court said the secret was never the candidate's existence. It was the current resume taken from Columbia's database.
The second placement involved a client contact at Nomura. After the recruiter was fired, he used that contact to place another candidate and split a $22,000 fee with EJR. He had signed a Duty of Loyalty Agreement promising to keep client information confidential. The court found he broke it (HRD America).
Those fees aren't what the court awarded. The appeals court left in place damages of $12,951.37 and $48,614.50, about $61,600 in total. The official decision is on the New York courts website.
CyberCoders v. Cooke and Benedetto (2025)
Two employees of CyberCoders, a permanent placement recruiting firm, resigned on February 17, 2025. According to Littler, the law firm representing CyberCoders, ten more people from the same recruiting division resigned within 48 hours after the pair solicited them.
CyberCoders sued on March 6. On April 15, a federal judge in Florida granted a preliminary injunction. It bars the two former employees from certain competing and soliciting activity in recruiting and staffing for 12 months. The court found CyberCoders was likely to succeed on its breach of contract claims. These details come from Littler's April 2025 announcement (Littler).
Do Contracts Stop Recruiters From Taking Clients?
Contracts help, but they rarely stop it alone. Non-solicitation and confidentiality agreements give you grounds to act once a recruiter crosses the line. Both cases above turned on signed agreements. A loyalty agreement settled the client contact question for Columbia Technology. Restrictive covenants won CyberCoders a 12-month injunction less than six weeks after it filed suit.
Look at what those agreements couldn't do, though. CyberCoders had already lost twelve people before any court got involved. Columbia Technology's damages came to about $61,600 after a trial and an appeal. Sasqua had no signed agreement and few controls on its database, so it got no trade secret protection at all.
Enforceability also depends on your state and on how the agreement is written. Noncompetes face the tightest limits. Several states ban them completely. Have an employment lawyer review your agreements.
Contracts work best as one layer of protection. The other layer is limiting how much a recruiter can take out the door. Our post on client theft by employees goes deeper on that point.
How Can Agencies Protect Their Clients and Candidates?
Recruiters need real relationships to do the job. The aim is to keep the contact data behind those relationships inside the agency.
- Have every recruiter sign before they get access. Confidentiality and non-solicitation agreements on day one are part of what courts look for. Sasqua shows what happens without them.
- Restrict exports. Limit bulk downloads from the ATS to managers. Review large exports regularly and check the log whenever someone gives notice.
- Where your ATS allows it, hide phone numbers and emails in search results. Recruiters can still review profiles and open contact details when they're ready to reach out.
- Put a second person on every key client. An account manager or the owner should know the hiring managers too.
- Set a LinkedIn policy early. Decide how connections made on the job are handled and put it in writing. The law here is unsettled, so get legal advice on the wording.
- Keep calls and emails with clients and candidates on company systems instead of personal phones.
- Review the tools connected to your ATS. Remove extensions and integrations nobody needs and limit what the rest can read.
- Plan access changes for every departure. When a recruiter gives notice, trim their access to what they need to finish open placements. Remove the rest when they leave, or sooner for higher-risk exits.
Keeping communication on company systems is the part emailautomation.ai handles. Recruiters email and call hiring managers and candidates through the platform, but the real addresses and phone numbers stay hidden from them. If a candidate types a cell number into a reply, the system hides it before the recruiter sees it.
Owners decide what managers and recruiters can each view, so access matches each person's role.
Bulk emails go out to a candidate pool without the list being exposed. An AI agent trained on your past conversations can also take care of routine replies and calls.
None of this stops a recruiter from remembering a client's name. It does limit how much contact data leaves with them.
What Should You Do if You Suspect Client Poaching?
Move quickly, but confirm the facts before you accuse anyone.
- 1.Preserve the evidence. Save ATS access and export logs, email records and any messages clients forward to you.
- 2.Limit access. Reduce the recruiter's permissions to what their current work requires.
- 3.Protect live placements. Have a manager or the owner call the affected clients and candidates directly.
- 4.Write down what you know. Note dates, names and what each person told you.
- 5.Call an employment lawyer before you confront anyone. They can tell you whether an agreement was broken and what to do next.
Speed matters. CyberCoders filed suit 17 days after the resignations and had its injunction within two months of them. For the early signals to watch, see our post on warning signs an employee is poaching your clients.
Protect Both Sides of the Desk
A staffing agency can lose a client and the candidates lined up for that client in the same week. Setting up protection before a recruiter resigns is far easier than going to court afterward.
Start your free trial of emailautomation.ai and try it with one recruiting team first. To see it in action beforehand, book a demo.
Recruitment Agency FAQs
Can a recruiter take clients when they leave an agency?
That depends on what they signed and on state law. Non-solicitation and confidentiality agreements often restrict contact with clients and candidates for a set period. An employment lawyer can tell you how yours would apply.
Is a candidate database a trade secret?
It can be. In the Columbia Technology case, a New York court treated a current resume taken from the firm's database as protected information. Courts also look at whether the agency kept that database confidential.
Who owns a recruiter's LinkedIn connections?
US law gives no single answer. The outcome depends heavily on the agreement in place and the facts of each case. A written policy makes your position clearer.
What should an agency do when a recruiter resigns?
Review their system access straight away and leave only what they need to finish open placements. Check recent exports from the ATS. A manager should also contact that recruiter's key clients during the handover.
Sources
- Weekly Economic & Business Outlook: Internal Staffing Turnover On the Rise, American Staffing Association, March 2025
- Court holds recruiting firm liable for misusing rival's candidate data, HRD America, July 2026
- Columbia Technology decision, 2026 NY Slip Op 04140, New York Appellate Division, First Department, June 2026
- Littler Team Secures A Quick Preliminary Injunction for CyberCoders, Littler, April 2025
- How LinkedIn Torpedoed One Employer's Trade Secrets Claim, ERE, November 2010
- LinkedIn Torpedoes Employer's Trade Secrets Claim, Fisher Phillips, October 2010
Ready to put AI to work on your emails?
Talk to AI Email Automation about your campaigns.







